海角视频

U of T expert on why the 'migrant caravan' should not be demonized

Photo of migrant talking to U.S. border agents
A Honduran migrant converses with U.S border agents on the other side of razor wire on Nov. 25 after agents fired tear gas at migrants pressuring to cross into the U.S. from Tijuana, Mexico (photo by Ramon Espinosa/AP)

On American Thanksgiving weekend, United States Customs and Border Protection (CBP) agents gassed children with chemical weapons at the U.S.-Mexico border at San Ysidro, America鈥檚 busiest border crossing.

Social and traditional media were awash in of family members fleeing tear gas canisters, pepper spray and flash bang grenades, some running without shoes and in diapers.

A low-flying CBP helicopter used the down draft from its rotors to into a Mexican-side canal where many people were gathered.
 
President Donald Trump had earlier authorized CBP agents to as assault with a firearm. He had been anticipating the arrival at the border of a procession of 5,000 to 7,000 asylum-seekers, all on foot and largely fleeing , and in Honduras and other Central American countries.

The United States has created a backlog at the border by employing a ticketed system of entries and forcing asylum-seekers to . 鈥淲e鈥檙e not turning people away,鈥 CBP Commissioner Kevin McAleenan told reporters in October.

Humanitarian crisis

It is not surprising that the mayor of Tijuana has declared a and is hoping for more financial support to provide to migrants.

Trump, meanwhile, has consistently employed , xenophobic, and fascistic rhetoric when discussing the migrants.

In the leadup to November鈥檚 midterm elections, the president referred to asylum-seekers as 鈥溾 鈥渉uman shields,鈥 an 鈥渋nsurgency鈥 and 鈥溾

This language created a false pretence to deploy to the border, double the number who are stationed in Syria.

The president recently defended the Thanksgiving tear gassing, claiming that three CBP agents had been by rocks and stones thrown by migrants whose 鈥渧iolence is very strong.鈥 However, his account by McAleenan, and the CBP鈥檚 , that 鈥渢he likelihood of violence directed against CBP personnel along the border is minimal.鈥

California ponders legal action

These horrific tear gas attacks have fuelled , as well as a probe into of lobbing chemical weapons over the border, with the state of California debating .

We should question how and why the Trump administration is creating a that then purports to justify the militarization of the border against . The administration is repelling the asylum-seekers by any means necessary, forcing them to remain in squalid conditions and denying them access to their rights.

Using military language, as Trump does repeatedly as commander-in-chief, fuels widespread perceptions of migrants as 鈥渋nvaders.鈥 The language creates the false impression of danger. The group becomes seen as a threat that must be contained and pushed out.

It results in a show of power to citizens that their government is in charge of the immigration and asylum systems, and that they should trust and feel protected by these tough officials.

This rhetoric reinforces an , leading to that then justify violence to repel foreigners, including women and diapered children.

False associations with disease

There is a long history of falsely foreigners with disease, and this is no exception. that the migrants have 鈥渉ealth issues鈥 as falsely that the newcomers will conjure up the long-eradicated smallpox and bring it into the United States.

Javier Hernanez, of Tijuana, Mexico, wears a Christmas hat as he looks out over the border wall separating Tijuana from San Diego on Dec. 7. Trump says Congress should provide all the money he wants for his promised U.S.-Mexico border wall, calling illegal immigration a threat to the well-being of every American community' (photo by Gregory Bull/AP)

While it鈥檚 certainly a fallacy that diseases respect borders, the use of the border as a 鈥渃ordon sanitaire鈥 to protect the country is a powerful tool to deploy.

The Trump administration insists on putting forward harmful actions to back up its rhetoric of hate. It鈥檚 going to build a ; it will separate from their caregivers, confining them to despite signing an purporting to end the practice; and now attacking men, women and children on the Mexican side of the border with tear gas.

have long been protesting the efforts to scare citizens about this .

It鈥檚 time to start listening to these voices, and to react with compassion to asylum-seekers not with violence, hate and militarized language.The Conversation

 is an adjunct professor and the interim associate director of the Ethics, Society, and Law Program at Trinity College, University of Toronto.

This article is republished from under a Creative Commons license. Read the .

Topics

The Bulletin Brief logo

Subscribe to The Bulletin Brief

The Conversation Canada